What can go wrong
A nuclear plant's pressure boundary, the reactor vessel, its head and nozzles, the primary piping, pumps, pressurizer and steam generators, is designed with large margins, but it is not immune to damage. The mechanisms inspection looks for include:
- Stress corrosion cracking: primary water stress corrosion cracking (PWSCC) in nickel alloys such as Alloy 600 and its weld metals in pressurized water reactors, and intergranular stress corrosion cracking (IGSCC), which affected stainless steel piping in boiling water reactors.
- Steam generator tube degradation: wear, pitting, denting and cracking of the thousands of thin tubes that separate reactor coolant from the secondary system.
- Flow-accelerated corrosion (FAC) thinning carbon steel piping in steam and feedwater systems.
- Fatigue, including thermal fatigue where hot and cold water mix, and boric acid corrosion of carbon steel where borated reactor coolant leaks.
Boric acid corrosion produced one of the most serious events in US nuclear history. At the Davis-Besse plant in Ohio, inspections during a refueling outage that began in February 2002 found axial cracking in control rod drive mechanism nozzles that had let reactor coolant leak through the pressure boundary. In early March, after boric acid deposits were cleaned away, a large cavity was found in the carbon steel head beside one of the nozzles. Where the damage was deepest, about 3/8 inch of material remained, essentially only the stainless steel cladding on the inside of the head, a layer never meant to hold reactor pressure on its own. The NRC's overview of the event sets out what was found, and the event led to closer inspection of reactor vessel heads and their nozzles across the industry.
Where NDT is used
- Ultrasonic testing (UT), increasingly phased array, is the main volumetric method for inservice examination of reactor vessel welds, nozzles, dissimilar metal welds and piping welds. Examinations are often automated and performed remotely because of radiation.
- Eddy current testing (ET) of steam generator tubes, with bobbin, rotating and array probes, is one of the biggest inspection tasks of a pressurized water reactor outage. The approach is covered in our guide to tubing analysis.
- Visual examination (VT) in ASME Section XI comes in three kinds: VT-1 looks for discontinuities such as cracks and corrosion, VT-2 looks for evidence of leakage during pressure tests, and VT-3 checks the general mechanical and structural condition of components and supports. Much of it is done remotely with cameras.
- Surface methods such as penetrant and magnetic particle testing, and radiography, are used mainly in construction, repair and replacement.
- Thickness monitoring tracks FAC in secondary piping under each plant's FAC program.
How inspection fits into plant operation
Most inservice inspection happens during refueling outages, typically every 18 to 24 months, when the reactor is shut down. Work is planned years in advance: ASME Section XI organizes inspection into ten-year inspection intervals, and each outage completes a planned share of the examinations due in that interval. Before a plant or a replaced component enters service, a preservice inspection records a baseline for later comparison.
Outages are short and radiation exposure is limited and tracked for every worker, so examinations are planned to be done once, correctly. That is a large part of why automated ultrasonics and remote visual tools are so widely used.
Rules and requirements
- 10 CFR 50.55a incorporates the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code into NRC regulations, with conditions of its own. ASME Section III covers construction of nuclear components, and ASME Section XI covers inservice inspection.
- Performance demonstration. Section XI's Appendix VIII requires ultrasonic procedures, equipment and personnel to prove, on specimens containing real flaws, that they can detect and size them. In the US, those demonstrations are carried out through the industry's Performance Demonstration Initiative, which EPRI administers. The NRC's conditions add, for example, that personnel qualified under Appendix VIII must receive eight hours of hands-on training each year on specimens containing cracks (10 CFR 50.55a(b)(2)(xiv)).
- Personnel certification for Section XI examinations builds on ANSI/ASNT CP-189, with added requirements from Section XI and the NRC's conditions. Personnel qualification is a subject in itself, and we keep this article to the overview.
- Quality assurance. 10 CFR Part 50, Appendix B sets the NRC's quality assurance criteria, including control of special processes such as NDT and the records that prove it; ASME NQA-1 is widely used to meet them. 10 CFR Part 21 requires evaluation and reporting of defects in safety-related items and services, which can include inspection services.
- Internationally, the IAEA publishes safety standards and guidance that many national regulators draw on.
Advanced reactors
New reactor designs, including small modular reactors, bring different materials, temperatures and coolants, and in some cases factory-built modules. The principles of inspection stay the same: know the damage mechanisms, choose methods that can find them, and demonstrate that they do. How codes and inspection programs adapt to these designs is still developing, and it is worth following closely.
What this means for utilities and suppliers
For a utility, NDT quality comes down to discipline: qualified procedures and people for every examination, complete and retrievable records, and prompt evaluation of anything found. For suppliers of NDT services, the bar is higher than in most industries: a quality program meeting Appendix B, personnel certified to the right standard with the required training, and procedures demonstrated where the rules demand it.
Frequently asked questions
What is inservice inspection (ISI) at a nuclear plant?
ISI is the program of periodic examinations of pressure-retaining components, such as reactor vessel welds, piping welds, pumps, valves and supports, required by ASME Section XI as incorporated into NRC regulations by 10 CFR 50.55a. It is organized into ten-year intervals, with a share of the examinations done at each refueling outage.
Who qualifies ultrasonic examiners for nuclear plants?
Under ASME Section XI Appendix VIII, ultrasonic procedures, equipment and personnel must pass performance demonstrations on specimens containing real flaws. In the US these are carried out through the Performance Demonstration Initiative administered by EPRI. Examiners are also certified by their employers under CP-189-based written practices.
What is 10 CFR 50 Appendix B?
It is the NRC's set of quality assurance criteria for nuclear power plants. It covers, among other things, control of special processes such as nondestructive examination, qualification of the people and procedures used, and the records that prove it. Suppliers of safety-related services must work under a quality program that meets it.
How NDT LLC can help
NDT LLC helps NDT service companies and suppliers prepare for nuclear work: written practices and procedures, personnel qualification records, quality program alignment and audit readiness. Contact us to discuss your needs.
This article is general information for a business audience, not engineering, legal or regulatory advice. Always work to the current edition of the codes, standards, regulations and manufacturer data that apply to your equipment and contracts.
NDT LLC is an independent consulting firm. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), ASME, EPRI, ASNT, the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), or any other organization named in this article; names are used only to identify the organizations and documents referred to.